FEMA P908 2012
$35.10
FEMA P-908 – Mitigation Assessment Team Report Spring 2011 Tornadoes: April 25-28 and May 22, Building Performance Observations, Recommendations, and Technical Guidance
Published By | Publication Date | Number of Pages |
FEMA | 2012 | 512 |
0
PDF Catalog
PDF Pages | PDF Title |
---|---|
1 | Front Cover |
2 | Disclaimer |
3 | Title Page |
4 | Members of the Mitigation Assessment Team |
5 | Dedication |
6 | Cover Photo Captions |
7 | Executive Summary |
8 | Observations |
11 | Recommendations |
15 | Table of Contents |
23 | List of Figures |
43 | List of Tables |
47 | Chapter 1. Introduction |
48 | 1.1 FEMA Mitigation Assessment Teams 1.1.1 Purpose of the 2011 Tornado Mitigation Assessment Team |
50 | 1.1.2 Team Composition 1.1.3 Methodology |
52 | 1.1.4 Types of Buildings and Structures Assessed by the MAT |
55 | 1.1.5 Involvement of State and Local Agencies 1.1.6 Past Tornado MAT Deployments |
57 | 1.2 Terminology and Background for Tornado Protection Alternatives |
60 | 1.3 2011 Tornado Recovery Advisories |
61 | 1.4 Organization of Report |
63 | Chapter 2. Meteorological Background and Tornado Events of 2011 |
64 | 2.1 Tornado Prediction |
65 | 2.2 Enhanced Fujita Scale |
66 | 2.3 Tornado Winds and Damage Patterns |
68 | 2.4 National Weather Service Tornado Warning Strategies and Ratings 2.4.1 Tornado Watches and Warnings |
69 | 2.4.2 NWS EF Rating Assignments |
70 | 2.5 Tornado Events of Spring 2011 2.5.1 April 25–28, 2011 Tornadoes in the Mid-South Area of the United States 2.5.1.1 April 18–24, 2011 |
72 | 2.5.1.2 April 25, 2011 |
73 | 2.5.1.3 April 26, 2011 2.5.1.4 April 27, 2011, 2:00 a.m. to 12:00 p.m. |
74 | 2.5.1.5 April 27, 2011, 2:30 p.m. to 3:00 p.m.: Philadelphia, MS, Tornado #24, and Cullman, AL, Tornado #38 |
75 | 2.5.1.6 April 27, 2011, 3:00 p.m.: Hackleburg to Huntsville, AL, Tornado #40 |
76 | 2.5.1.7 April 27, 2011, 3:30 p.m.: Smithville, MS, Tornado #43 |
77 | 2.5.1.8 April 27, 2011, 3:38 p.m.: Cordova, AL, Tornado #41/#49 |
78 | 2.5.1.9 April 27, 2011: Macon County Supercell Thunderstorm, Tornado #46 |
79 | 2.5.2 May 22, 2011 Storms in Missouri |
80 | 2.5.2.1 Summary of Synoptic Setting and Mesoscale Environment |
81 | 2.5.2.2 Damage and Path of the Joplin Tornado |
83 | Chapter 3. Design and Construction Considerations |
84 | 3.1 Effects of Wind Loading on Structures |
88 | 3.2 Wind-Borne Debris |
90 | 3.2.1 Missile Types and Sizes |
93 | 3.2.2 Wind-Borne Missile Quantity |
95 | 3.3 Federal, State, and Local Regulations |
96 | 3.3.1 International Building Code and International Residential Code 3.3.2 International Codes and Storm Shelters |
97 | 3.3.3 State and Local Codes and Regulations in Areas Visited by the MAT |
99 | 3.3.3.1 Alabama |
100 | 3.3.3.2 Georgia 3.3.3.3 Mississippi 3.3.3.4 Tennessee |
101 | 3.3.3.5 Missouri |
103 | Chapter 4. Observations on Residential Building Performance |
104 | 4.1 One- and Two-Family Residences |
105 | 4.1.1 EF Rating Evaluation of Residential Buildings |
106 | 4.1.2 Description of Progressive Damage for One- and Two-Family Residential Buildings |
107 | 4.1.3 Loss of Roof Covering and Exterior Siding (DOD 2) |
108 | 4.1.4 Glazing Damage (DOD 3) |
110 | 4.1.5 Garage Doors Collapse Inward (DOD 4) |
112 | 4.1.6 Uplift of Roof Decks (DOD 4) |
115 | 4.1.7 Gable End Walls: Vulnerability Related to Uplift of Roof Deck (DOD 4) |
116 | 4.1.8 Entire House Shifts Off Foundation (DOD 5) |
117 | 4.1.9 Roof Structure Removed (DOD 6) |
120 | 4.1.10 Collapse of Framed Walls (DOD 6–9) |
122 | 4.1.11 Wall Framing-to-Foundation Connection Failure: Damage Related to Collapse of Framed Walls (DOD 7–9) |
126 | 4.2 Multi-Family Residences 4.2.1 EF Rating Evaluation of Multi-Family Residential Buildings 4.2.1 Chastain Manor Apartments (Tuscaloosa, AL) |
132 | 4.2.3 Mercy Village Apartments (Joplin, MO) |
137 | 4.3 Summary of Conclusions and Recommendations |
141 | Chapter 5. Observations on Commercial and Industrial Building Performance |
145 | 5.1 Tilt-Up Precast Concrete Walls with Steel Joist Roof System 5.1.1 Description of Construction Method and Load Path |
146 | 5.1.2 Typical Failure Modes Observed by the MAT 5.1.3 Home Depot (Joplin, MO) |
156 | 5.2 Load Bearing Masonry with Steel Joist Roof System |
157 | 5.2.1 Description of Construction Methods and Load Path 5.2.2 Typical Failure Modes Observed by the MAT |
158 | 5.2.3 Strip Mall – Dry Cleaner, Two Large Retail Stores, and Other Stores (Tuscaloosa, AL) |
162 | 5.2.4 Jefferson Metro Care (Birmingham, AL) |
167 | 5.2.5 Walmart (Joplin, MO) |
176 | 5.3 Light Steel Frame Buildings 5.3.1 Description of Construction Method and Load Path 5.3.2 Typical Failure Modes Observed by the MAT |
177 | 5.3.3 Fitness Center (Tuscaloosa, AL) |
179 | 5.3.4 St. Paul’s United Methodist Church (Joplin, MO) |
182 | 5.4 Reinforced Concrete Frame with CMU Infill Walls |
183 | 5.4.1 Description of Construction Method and Load Path 5.4.2 Typical Failure Modes Observed by the MAT 5.4.3 Ozark Center for Autism (Joplin, MO) |
188 | 5.5 Summary of Conclusions and Recommendations |
193 | Chapter 6. Observations on Critical Facility Performance: Schools |
196 | 6.1 Building Performance 6.1.1 Alberta Elementary School (Tuscaloosa, AL) |
202 | 6.1.2 University Place Elementary School (Tuscaloosa, AL) |
210 | 6.1.3 Ringgold High School and Ringgold Middle School (Ringgold, GA) 6.1.3.1 Ringgold High School |
218 | 6.1.3.2 Ringgold Middle School |
221 | 6.1.4 Joplin East Middle School (Joplin, MO) |
227 | 6.1.5 Joplin High School (Joplin, MO) |
235 | 6.2 Operational Issues |
237 | 6.2.1 Severe Weather Policy |
238 | 6.2.2 Severe Weather Communication and Decision Making |
239 | 6.2.3 Changes for the Future |
240 | 6.2.4 Summary 6.3 Summary of Conclusions and Recommendations |
241 | Chapter 7. Observations on Critical Facility Performance: Healthcare, First Responder, and Emergency Operations Centers |
243 | 7.1 Hospitals and Health Care Facilities |
244 | 7.1.1 Birmingham Nursing and Rehabilitation Center (Birmingham, AL) |
247 | 7.1.2 LaRocca Nursing Home (Tuscaloosa, AL) |
252 | 7.1.3 Greenbriar Nursing Home (Joplin, MO) |
255 | 7.1.4 St. John’s Medical Center (Joplin, MO) |
262 | 7.2 First Responder Facilities (Police and Fire) 7.2.1 Fultondale Municipal Complex (Fultondale, AL) |
264 | 7.2.1.1 Fire Department |
265 | 7.2.1.2 Library and “Shelter” |
266 | 7.2.1.3 Building and Inspections Department |
268 | 7.2.1.4 City Hall |
269 | 7.2.1.5 Summary of MAT EF Ratings for the Fulton Dale Municipal Complex 7.2.2 Tuscaloosa Fire Station 4 (Tuscaloosa, AL) |
274 | 7.2.3 Webster’s Chapel Volunteer Fire Department (Wellington, AL) |
277 | 7.2.4 Smithville Police Department (Smithville, MS) |
282 | 7.3 Emergency Operations Centers 7.3.1 Tuscaloosa EOC (Tuscaloosa, AL) |
289 | 7.3.2 Cullman County EOC (Cullman, AL) |
291 | 7.4 Summary of Conclusions and Recommendations |
295 | Chapter 8. Observations on Infrastructure Performance |
296 | 8.1 Water Treatment and Distribution Facilities |
297 | 8.1.1 Tuscaloosa Water Works (Tuscaloosa, AL) |
300 | 8.1.2 Smithville Water Treatment and Distribution System (Smithville, MS) |
305 | 8.2 WasteWater Treatment Facilities 8.2.1 Tuscaloosa Waste Water Treatment Plant and Collection System (Tuscaloosa, AL) |
306 | 8.3 Towers (Communications and Antennas) |
307 | 8.3.1 Free-Standing Towers 8.3.1.1 Latticed 250-Foot EMS Communications Tower (Tuscaloosa, AL) |
310 | 8.3.1.2 Latticed 300-Foot Cellular Tower (Tuscaloosa, AL) |
313 | 8.3.1.3 Solid Cellular Tower, 13th Street (Tuscaloosa, AL) |
315 | 8.3.2 Guyed Towers 8.3.2.1 300-Foot Guyed Cellular Tower (Smithville, MS) |
319 | 8.4 Summary of Conclusions and Recommendations |
321 | Chapter 9. Observations on Tornado Refuge Areas, Hardened Areas, and Safe Rooms |
322 | 9.1 Terminology and Examples |
323 | 9.1.1 Hardened Areas: Areas Designed to Provide Some Protection |
324 | 9.1.2 Storm Shelters and Safe Rooms: Areas Designed for Life-Safety Protection |
327 | 9.2 Tornado Refuge Areas 9.2.1 Tornado Refuge Areas in Residences |
328 | 9.2.1.1 Core Remnants |
330 | 9.2.1.2 Basement Areas |
333 | 9.2.1.3 Tornado Refuge Areas in Multi-Family Buildings or Complexes |
334 | 9.2.2 Tornado Refuge in Commercial and Industrial Buildings: Planned Tornado Refuge Areas 9.2.2.1 Walmart (Joplin, MO ) |
335 | 9.2.2.2 Lowe’s Home Improvement Store (Tuscaloosa, AL) |
337 | 9.2.2.3 Home Depot (Joplin, MO) |
339 | 9.3 Hardened Structures, Rooms, and Areas Not Designed to Defined Criteria |
340 | 9.3.1 Hardened Structures for Residential Use 9.3.1.1 Below-Ground Applications |
342 | 9.3.1.2 Above-Ground Applications |
344 | 9.3.2 Hardened Structures Used as Community Tornado Refuge Areas 9.3.2.1 Above-Ground Applications |
345 | 9.3.2.2 Below-Ground Applications |
346 | 9.4 Safe Rooms and Storm Shelters 9.4.1 Above- and Below-Ground Alternatives |
348 | 9.4.2 Prefabricated versus Site-Built Alternatives |
349 | 9.4.3 Residential Safe Rooms and Storm Shelters 9.4.3.1 Below-Ground Applications |
351 | 9.4.3.2 Above-Ground Applications |
353 | 9.4.4 Non-Residential and Community Safe Rooms |
354 | 9.4.4.1 Brookwood and Phil Campbell Community Safe Rooms (AL) |
357 | 9.4.4.2 Brookside Fire Station and Community Safe Room (Brookside, AL) |
358 | 9.4.4.3 Seneca Intermediate School (Seneca, MO) |
362 | 9.5 Travel Time to Community Safe Rooms, Storm Shelters, and Tornado Refuge Areas |
363 | 9.6 Compliance Issues with FEMA 320, FEMA 361, and the ICC 500 9.6.1 Identifying Design Criteria Used for Safe Rooms and Storm Shelters |
364 | 9.6.2 Accessibility to Safe Rooms and Storm Shelters |
365 | 9.6.3 Ventilation for Safe Rooms and Storm Shelters 9.6.4 Toilet Facilities for Community Safe Rooms and Storm Shelters 9.6.5 Location and Labeling of Safe Rooms and Storm Shelters |
366 | 9.6.6 Tools and Other Equipment within Safe Rooms and Storm Shelters |
367 | 9.7 Summary of Conclusions and Recommendations |
371 | Chapter 10. Conclusions of the 2011 Tornado MAT |
372 | 10.1 Codes and Standards 10.1.1 Residential Buildings |
374 | 10.1.2 Commercial and Industrial Buildings 10.1.3 Critical Facilities |
375 | 10.1.4 Infrastructure Facilities 10.1.5 Tornado Refuge Areas, Hardened Areas, and Safe Rooms |
376 | 10.2 Performance of Residential Buildings |
377 | 10.3 Performance of Commercial and Industrial Buildings |
378 | 10.3.1 Communications and Operations 10.3.2 Building Performance/Building Design |
379 | 10.4 Performance of Critical Facility Buildings |
381 | 10.5 Performance of Infrastructure Facilities |
382 | 10.6 Performance of Tornado Refuge Areas, Hardened Areas, and Safe Rooms 10.6.1 General |
384 | 10.6.2 Residential Safe Rooms and Storm Shelters |
386 | 10.6.3 Community Safe Rooms, Storm Shelters, and Tornado Refuge Areas |
387 | 10.7 EF Scale |
388 | 10.8 Post-Tornado Imagery |
389 | Chapter 11. Recommendations of the 2011 Tornado MAT |
390 | 11.1 Codes and Standards 11.1.1 Residential Buildings |
391 | 11.1.2 Commercial and Industrial Buildings |
392 | 11.1.3 Critical Facilities 11.1.4 Tornado Refuge Areas, Hardened Areas, and Safe Rooms |
393 | 11.2 Residential Construction |
394 | 11.3 Commercial and Industrial Construction 11.3.1 Occupant Notification and Operations |
395 | 11.3.2 Detailing and Connections |
396 | 11.4 Critical Facilities |
397 | 11.4.1 Existing Critical Facilities 11.4.2 New Critical Facilities |
398 | 11.5 Infrastructure Facilities |
399 | 11.6 Tornado Refuge Areas, Hardened Areas, and Safe Rooms |
400 | 11.7 EF Scale |
401 | 11.8 Post-Tornado Imagery |
403 | Appendix A. Acknowledgments FEMA Contributors |
404 | Other Contributors |
409 | Appendix B. References |
415 | Appendix C. Acronyms |
419 | Appendix D. Glossary |
427 | Appendix E. EF Scale Summary |
435 | Appendix F. Recovery Advisories for the Spring 2011 Tornadoes |
437 | Appendix F. RA1 |
443 | Appendix F. RA2 |
451 | Appendix F. RA3 |
457 | Appendix F. RA4 |
459 | Appendix F. RA5 |
465 | Appendix F. RA6 |
489 | Appendix G. Recommendations for One- and Two-Family Residential Buildings G.1 Purpose and Audience |
490 | G.2 Background and Applicability |
492 | G.3 Discussion of Recommendations |
493 | G.3.1 Building Envelope Components G.3.1.1 Roof Coverings G.3.1.2 Wall Coverings |
494 | G.3.1.3 Masonry Veneer Attachment G.3.1.4 Glazing (Doors and Windows) |
495 | G.3.1.5 Garage Doors |
496 | G.3.2 Roof Systems and Connections G.3.2.1 Roof Decking and Decking Attachment |
497 | G.3.2.2 Soffits G.3.2.3 Roof-to-Wall Connectors |
499 | G.3.3.1 Sill Plate Attachment |
500 | G.3.3.2 Wall Sheathing |
505 | G.3.3.3 Top Plate Splices G.3.3.4 Openings in Walls |
507 | G.3.3.5 Wall-to-Floor Connection |
510 | G.4 References |